Friday, November 8, 2013

11/9 At the wire

Breakfast: Oatmeal and cranberry sauce (the last of both of those)
Lunch: Potato salad with hard boiled egg, ramen noodles with left over chicken
Dinner: Chicken Soup/Stew (Stoup?) with potatoes, peas, carrots

So what I have I learned? In some ways, the experiment was harder than reality because I did have things left over, so I could eventually buy spices and maybe even the occasional onion. That would make the food more appetizing. I would say that it is possible to eat reasonably well on $30 per week, but there isn't much room in the budget for extras like sweets or soda. Some proteins, like fish, are probably only ever going to be in the form of frozen, i.e. fish sticks. I bought store-brand/value everything and the good news is that the quality of those items is acceptable.

Another way that it was probably more difficult: I think the poor have access to other sources of free food like soup kitchens (http://www.cnn.com/video/data/2.0/video/us/2013/11/01/lead-flores-food-stamp-benefits-reduced.cnn.html) and food pantries. Certainly children can get free lunch and sometimes free breakfast. We have Micah's backpack (https://www.google.com/search?q=micah%27s+backpack&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a) in Blacksburg that supplies kids with food for weekends. That said, if you Google "free food blacksburg", you get http://www.freefood.org/c/va-blacksburg, and there are no listings. I'm only aware of MCEAP (http://civic.bev.net/mceap/) and the Christmas store (http://www.mcchristmasstore.org/)

I also tried very hard not to waste any food. Not that I usually waste much food, but if you are forced to worry about calories, you have to eat leftovers.

At my local supermarket, there are frequently opportunities such that if you buy ten total items (out of a large assortment of choices), you can save $5. What I noticed is that if you don't have much money, it is difficult to take advantage of these great deals. Like buying the larger size of something, because per ounce it is much cheaper, that only works if you can afford the initial higher cash outlay. I knew this, of course, but it hit home this week.

If the goal is to eat a nutritious, well-balanced diet, then for the money, there isn't room for coffee or tea (which don't contribute to either). Any extra money that I would have had for week 2 (because I wouldn't have to buy mayonnaise again ;)) should be spent on buying more vegetables and a wider variety of fruit. One pound of ground beef and one package of chicken (or something equivalent) are perfectly good animal proteins (for the money), though I did only have to prepare six dinners.

In the end, I had the equivalent of most of a small jar of mayonnaise, a few eggs, about a pint of milk, a few potatoes, about a quarter of a jar of peanut butter, some peas and a little orange juice?

It's certainly stressful to wonder if you will have enough food to eat and we know that stress is bad for you. Even the stress I felt when I wondered if I had "enough" money to pay for my second round of shopping was noticeable. The chicken was on sale, but it originally rang up as the full price and for a second, I panicked, thinking that surely I had not miscalculated that badly.

In the end, despite the fact that I COULD eat for $30, I don't understand why we (as a nation) would want to cut that subsidy to the poor to balance the budget. Even an extra $5 a week would mean something like a box of frozen spinach, a box of frozen broccoli and some apples and oranges.

I'm going to guess that I usually spend more like $100 a week on food (I don't even know), so I'll donate the difference to a food bank. I cut coupons and shops sales and frequently buy the store brand, so it's not that I'm cavalier about food cost, far from it. But food just seems like someplace not to cut corners (compared to say better cable TV or internet access or a more generous cell phone plan). 

Thanks for reading.

Gordon

11/8 On the home stretch

In the book I am reading, a character (a house cleaner) is feeding three adults on $30-50 per week. That would be impossible. I wouldn't even want to try.

I changed my plan a little from yesterday. I left out the cranberry (saving it for peanut butter) and had poulet a l'orange that wasn't bad. Then I made rice gruel (jook, in the cantonese dialect) from the chicken bones for breakfast today. That's it for the rice.

For lunch, I ate the leftover jook and a couple of peanut butter and cranberry sandwiches.
For dinner, I will make mashed potatoes with pepper gravy and pan-fried chicken. Peas. Peanut and banana for dessert.

My friend, Diego, has rightly pointed out that we have both a hunger problem and an obesity problem in this country, but the same part of the population can be affected by one or both of these maladies. This might seem bizarre, but viewed as a nutrition problem, it makes more sense. By our Government subsidizing corn and other storable grains and therefore subsidizing meat and not fruits and vegetables, we are making the problem worse. It only makes sense that people on a fixed budget will eat less expensive things.

On top of that shameful situation, I'm pretty sure that if I had to slaughter my own cow or chicken, I would eat less meat. We just make it too sterile in this country, the way we've separated food production from consumption. That said, I think I would still eat meat, because I've cleaned fish and cooked lobster and crab and mussels. But I would definitely eat less. And I would probably start hunting because to me, eating something that has gotten to live a life running around seems better than something confined to a feedlot.

This week, about 2/3 of my meals have been lacto-ovo vegetarian. Normally, it is probably closer to 1/3. My cholesterol is a little high, so eating less meat is a good thing, but I doubt if I am going to change much long term. I didn't discover anything new that I really like to eat (although oatmeal and cranberry sauce isn't bad). That said, I vowed a few years ago to try to eat less meat and that really is the point: replace one meal a week with a vegetarian/vegan option and then just slowly add more.

Being Chinese, this is both easy and difficult: difficult because the cuisine is pretty heavily focused on meat, but easy because it's not a huge steak or a pot roast, but rather a little meat and a lot of vegetables.

One change that I could see making permanent: the small effort of making a pound of ground beef last three dinners instead of two (which for me would have been normal). This makes a big difference and made me eat more vegetables.

Thursday, November 7, 2013

11/7 On the far turn

Perhaps I'm being overly analytical, but it seems to me that by eating the way I am, I generate hardly any garbage. Prepared foods mean extra packaging, mean garbage. I've only thrown away the plastic packaging from the ground beef, the ramen and the stuff from the mac and cheese. On my normal Monday, I pick up a sausage and egg biscuit at Hardee's (only a few minutes between blood draw and start of class). But then there are tea bags, soda cans, juice bottles, etc. that I'm not generating now.

Dinner last night was good bread and a tasty vegetable noodle soup made by my friend Aarnes. It was a nice treat to eat a variety of vegetables. I like peas and carrots, but not every day.

Breakfast: hashbrowns and eggs. peas and carrots (because I was still hungry)

Final shopping trip: with $6.92 to spend, I wanted to get some chicken. It turned out that I could buy 10 "value" chicken thighs for just under $5. That left enough for a can of Kroger brand frozen OJ and a couple of small bananas. Total cost: $6.91 including tax. The downside: I wasn't able to get one free soda (because I think I have to pay tax on it). Well, no great loss: now I have orange juice.

Lunch: An egg salad sandwich, and a pan-fried chicken thigh with left over rice from the other night. A tall glass of orange juice. Actually, a really good lunch.

One thing that is inescapable even for this somewhat unrealistic experiment: You don't go to the store at the beginning of the week (or month) and just start buying stuff the way you do when you aren't thinking about money. I put off buying chicken and OJ until I knew how things were going to go. If I had not been doing so well (in terms of calories), I would have bought the cheapest calories available: peanut butter and bread. Chicken is a luxury and so is OJ. And really, there was no money for junk food (although admittedly, I will have some stuff left over) The sad part is that an onion is a luxury.

I saved some of the frozen OJ for my dinner tonight: cranberry/orange glazed chicken with rice. I'm saving all of the bones to make soup with; that will be one meal with carrots, potatoes and peas. With five meals left (not counting these two), one will be oatmeal (which will use up the oatmeal and the cranberry sauce), one will be chicken salad sandwiches (which will use up all of the bread). Except for one package of ramen, after that, it will be all potatoes, all of the time. I guess egg potato salad is on the horizon.






Wednesday, November 6, 2013

11/6 Hump day

Breakfast: 3/4 cup (uncooked volume) Oatmeal with cranberry sauce. Not too bad actually. Hot and filling, though perhaps only temporarily.

Lunch: Two tuna and egg salad sandwiches.

Dinner: Vegan Supper Club (free food)

So now that from a calorie standpoint, I'm pretty sure $30 is doable, I've started thinking about the quality of my diet. Protein is no problem. Calories are no problem. I have bought almost exclusively whole food (the exceptions being tomato sauce, cranberry sauce and mayonnaise). I don't think any of the exceptions are bad choices. But the list of things that I should be able to buy include citrus (vitamin C), green leafy vegetables (B vitamins). I am getting some C from what I did buy and lots of A from the carrots. But a variety of vegetables would be desirable and on the whole, fresh vegetables are expensive. Except for bananas, most fresh fruit is pretty expensive too.

I was tempted to drink the free coffee at the table in front of my polling place yesterday. But I think it was a Republican table and as I was not going to vote for their candidates, it seemed dishonest. On the other hand, I have not felt much guilt at pilfering a mustard packet here and there.

It's time for me to spend the rest of my money. I've got $6.17 plus I am going to give myself another $0.75 because I should not have had to pay tax on my food. So I've got $6.92 to spend on a chicken and whatever else.

Ironically, yesterday a package was delivered to my house from D'Artagnan, an expensive food supplier. I had forgotten that I had ordered some things a while back. The box contained things like white truffle butter, which cost almost my whole week's allotment of money. Fortunately, almost everything was frozen, so I just popped the items back into the freezer, but the absurdity of the situation was not lost on me.

Something that is interesting but almost equally absurd: my garden still has good stuff to eat in it: kale, chard, carrots, parsnips, but for the purposes of the experiment, I can't eat any of  it. It makes me realize that supplementing a diet with home grown food is both economical and nutritional. There used to be a couple of untended apple trees in my neighborhood and Diego and I would ask the owners of we could pick their apples and they always said yes. We made some great applesauce. But the trees were cut down this year. :(

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

11/5 Missing coffee and tea

Lunch: 1.5 egg salad sandwiches (egg, mayo, stolen packet of mustard), chicken flavored ramen with a serving of peas.

Dinner: shepherd's pie (1/3 # ground beef, peas, carrots and mashed potatoes, a bit of beef ramen flavor packet), glass of milk
Shepherd's pie in ramekins


Breakfast (Tuesday) 2 fried eggs with hash browns and toast with peanut butter and cranberry sauce. A bit of leftover oatmeal with cranberry sauce.

Lunch: (canned) chili beans and rice

It's only Tuesday, but I'm pretty confident that I won't starve. I have tonight's dinner planned, plenty of potatoes, bread, eggs, vegetables and milk still and really only need to buy a chicken (which should last three meals). I have certainly not gone hungry and have not lost any weight. What I miss most is a variety of things to drink because right now, it's water or milk. My meals have been less than ideal, flavorwise, but not too bad. Nutritionally, I think the only major thing I'm missing is vitamin C.

One thing I've noticed: I'm not so much spending time thinking about what to eat in general terms, but rather how to avoid eating the same thing day after day. So far, I've had eggs and hash browns twice, but that's it for repeats in two and a half days (not counting peanut butter). I don't see how to avoid oatmeal again and egg salad sandwiches.

In that same vein, I've got the luxury of having time to cook, but I have a greater appreciation for things like Hamburger Helper than I did before. Overworked, tired Mom's and Dad's understandably turn to things like this to make ground beef something different from the ground beef two or three days before.

Dinner: boxed mac and cheese augmented with ground beef, and carrots and (frozen) peas.


Monday, November 4, 2013

11/4 Mondays are more difficult

Mondays are more difficult because I have to go and get my blood tested before I can eat anything. I also have to teach right afterwards. This means that I have to pack both breakfast and lunch when I leave the house.

Dinner last night: hamburger steak (1/3 pound) mixed with 1/4 cup oatmeal and 1/2 small can of tomato sauce. A serving of frozen peas. Mashed potatoes (~1 potato) with margarine and milk. I made gravy by mixing the fond with a little mashed potato, adding water and some seasoning from a ramen packet (see below). 1/2 Peanut butter and cranberry for dessert. Completely satisfying, if a little dull.

Breakfast today: peanut butter and banana sandwiches (2) and a carrot. Lots of water.

A number of prominent people such as the Governor of Oregon have tried to live for  a week on food stamps:
http://www.creators.com/opinion/mona-charen/can-you-live-on-food-stamps.html
(the above article challenges the idea that people are trying to live on just SNAP and I have already stipulated that this is probably an infrequent worst-case scenario)

Also, next week, residents of Atlanta Georgia have been challenged to try it too http://www.atlantamagazine.com/covereddish/2013/10/23/snap-challenge-live-on-food-stamps-for-a-week

so I'm not original in attempting this. But a few years ago, my friend Diego and I participated in the campus Ramadan event wherein on the last day of Ramadan, everyone was invited to fast from sun up to sundown: no water, no food. One thing I learned from that event: thinking about hunger is not the same thing as experiencing hunger. And likewise for me in this experiment, reading about it is not the same as experiencing it.

I bought two packages of raman ($0.20 ea) and priced mayonnaise. Rather than buy mayo (which I have a lot of already) I'm going to pretend that I bought a small jar ($1.59) and add the cost to my total. There is no way I would use up a whole jar in a week, so I will have some left over. With tax, that adds $2.05 to my $21.68 to give $23.73. I need to buy a chicken and I hope to get OJ.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

11/3 And so it begins...


Breakfast: about ¾ cup of oatmeal (precooked volume) with a banana and two pieces of toast with peanut butter and cranberry sauce. First thing I noticed is that oatmeal without brown sugar and cinnamon is pretty tasteless and boring.

Lunch: hash browns and two fried eggs

So far, I’m not hungry, but I’ve already noticed that I’m thinking a lot more about food. I’m thinking about what I can eat and I've spent a lot of time at the supermarket looking at prices. As a single guy, living alone, I don’t often plan my meals more than a few hours in advance, but I am now. And those of you who know me know that I already think about food all of the time, but it’s not the same thing: I’ve been thinking about the ways that I can use the ground beef that I bought yesterday. I’ve decided that 1/3 of a pound should be plenty of meat, meaning that I can prepare three meals. I have all of the ingredients for a decent (though probably tasteless) shepherd’s pie: ground beef, peas and carrots and potatoes (that I can mash). Tonight, I’m going to try to make a Salisbury steak and stretch my 1/3 pound with oatmeal and an egg. I don’t have any flour, so I’m wondering if I can grind rice to thicken the gravy. Mashed potatoes and peas.

It was pointed out to me that I haven’t included any ramen noodles in my weekly shopping. I think they are about $0.15 a package. I actually like ramen, but what I’m interested in is the spice packets to use to make my food more flavorful.

In Virginia, we have tax on food, even supermarket food. I think this is terrible. It’s 2.5%, but fortunately, SNAP beneficiaries don’t have to pay it on the food they use their benefits on. (They do have to pay it on prepared foods and things like soda). Still, for people earning hardly anything and paying money for their food, 2.5% on $30 a week is $0.75, which is about enough for a can of soup or that onion that I’ve been pining for. If SNAP beneficiaries spend some of their salary on food, that part is taxable. Our tax system is supposed to be progressive, but taxing grocery store food is regressive and really just plain wrong. I don’t have a problem with the tax on prepared food and soda.

Part of my motivation for this experiment is that I’m reading a book called Nickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich. It’s a non-fiction book about a woman who tries to survive on minimum wage in different parts of the country. I’ve often wondered why we need a minimum wage and I now realize that if companies can pay as little as they want, the government ends up subsidizing the companies by providing things like SNAP. I don’t know what the answer is, but I am pretty sure people who work an honest 8 hours a day should be able to feed and house themselves. And when I say feed, I mean better than ramen every night.

Saturday, November 2, 2013

11/2 - Shopping day

So I haven't technically even started this experiment and already I am facing a conundrum: the store overcharged me for the bag of potatoes and at my supermarket, if you catch them in an error, they give you the item for free. So I'm up $4 and I have my potatoes. Now it seems to me that the spirit of the challenge is to spend only $30, but I said before this started that if I found any money, I could keep it, and this is kind of like found money. Hence the conundrum. I think for now, I'll just bank the money, but the potatoes were supposed to cost $3.07 (not $3.99), so that's what I've included in the calculation.

What I've bought so far:

5# bag of russet potatoes                          3.07
loaf of Kroger bread                                    1.00
18 large eggs                                                 1.99
Imperial stick margarine                           0.89
1# value frozen peas                                   2.17
1 box Kroger mac and cheese                   0.69
1 quart whole milk                                      1.59
1 jar peanut butter                                      1.88
1# carrots                                                       0.89
2 bananas                                                       0.47
1 # ground chuck                                         1.99
1 can chili beans                                           0.69
1 sm can tomato sauce                               0.29
1 # rice (2.5 cups)                                        1.00                              
1 sm can tuna                                                0.89
3 cups oats                                                     0.63
cranberry sauce                                              1.00

total    (inc. tax)                                           21.68

So the first thing I've noticed is that you become much more aware of how much stuff costs when you only have so much to spend (no surprise). What came somewhat at a surprise is that on a budget, one would never buy an onion: 4 bananas is worth much more than one onion. Another thought: jam is rather expensive, but cranberry sauce (which could serve the same function) is pretty cheap. Similarly, $1 worth of pasta has much less value than $1 worth of rice. Oatmeal is really cheap. I don't know where I'm going to get vitamin C (OJ is expensive), but I bought some tomato sauce to try to get some C.

Based on what I already have, I think I have all of my breakfasts taken care of and three dinners. I can probably handle at least a couple of days of peanut butter and jelly, but lunches are a problem. I plan to make a potato salad, but mostly, I want to make hash browns for breakfast and dinner save the bread for lunch. My plan it to get a chicken later in the week and stretch it to three meals (one a soup meal, chicken and rice with peas and carrots; wish I could afford an onion). I've still got about $8 dollars to spend.

Friday, November 1, 2013

11/1 continued

If you are interested in the Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP), see http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap.

If you are interested in the decrease in SNAP benefits, see
http://money.cnn.com/2013/11/01/news/economy/food-stamps-families/index.html?hpt=hp_t2

and if you are interested in how much a person would receive in your state (in 2012), see
http://kff.org/other/state-indicator/avg-monthly-food-stamp-benefits/

In fairness, SNAP is intended to *supplement*, not *be* the money for food in a month. But if there are people who don't have other sources of income (like a lot of the people I've met at the Christmas Store, a charity where I met Molly, my donor), then regardless of the intention, the reality is * $128/month*.

Additional  rules that I've considered. I won't take advantage of any free food or drink opportunities that I have as a faculty member (like coffee and doughnuts). But if I should be lucky enough to find money (in a public space), I get to spend it (don't laugh, I found $0.60 the other day).

In the interest of full disclosure, I already have some of the foodstuffs that I would have bought for this experiment (like rice and oatmeal). I am going to price these out at the bulk food store and include the cost in my total. I also intend to limit my visit to the bulk food store to one visit because it is slightly out of the way. If I need to go more than once, I will walk (gas is precious too). The supermarket is within easy walking distance of my house.

11/1 - The experiment

Dear Friends,
Several of  you have asked me why I stopped the blog after I got out of the hospital and the answer was that I needed to set about the task of getting healthy again. Also, I didn't think much in my regular life was worth blogging about. Yet it was quite flattering to find out that people were interested in what I had to say.

If there's one thing I am bothered by more than anything else in this country, it's that there are hungry people. Like every fiscal conservative, I think that able-bodied people should be working (or at least trying to work), but you know what? I don't care if people are working or not: no one should be hungry in a country as rich as ours.

Meanwhile, people in Washington are cutting the SNAP benefit and people are going to get less with which to buy food. Now I understand that they temporarily raised the benefit when the economy went bad, but even at the higher level, it didn't seem like much. Can someone really live on the lower level? In Virginia, it's $128 per month or about $4.27 per day assuming a 30 day month. Really? That works out to only $1.42 per meal.

So in recognition of the cut in benefits that begins today (11/1/2013), I am going to try to live on $29.90 for a week and to blog about my experience. I am going to start on Sunday morning (today is Friday) and try to make it to next Saturday night. Frankly, I expect to fail. On the other hand, unlike many people who rely on SNAP benefits, I have time to cook, I have a local supermarket with fresh fruits and vegetables, a local bulk food store and I have knowledge about nutrition. I don't expect to eat tasty food, but perhaps I can eat balanced, healthy meals. I just don't want to starve.

The ground rules are that I have only $29.90 to spend. I will get one free dinner on Wednesday because I am a member of Vegan Supper Club and it's not my week to cook (a group of us get together once a week). I am going to allow myself one soda beyond my $29.90 because I pick up discarded bottle caps and have a certificate for a free soda from saving them. I'm going to let myself steal sugar and salt and pepper packets. I will let myself use any coupons that anyone could get for free (like in the mail or just out in public).

I hope you find this interesting. The purpose of this experiment is not to show that people can eat well on this amount of money (I don't think they can) because doing it for a week is nothing  compared to doing it for a lifetime. But I do think it will make me more aware of the challenges of living on a strict budget.